Art Help on color styles

[Turkey]

For the last month, I've been working on a comic which I'll start publishing during the Summer. Last night, I redesigned all the mayor characters, and this brought me to a predicament:

As you can see on the attachments, I've used two different coloring styles for the same character. The problem lies in the fact that I like both styles. However, for sakes of not getting confused, I can only use one. I need help on choosing which style.

[Kei]

[color=darkblue]Well, the one on the left makes it seems as if the character is either a) made of metal or b) made of plastic, while the other one seems a bit more like natural light. I don't know what kind of character it is, but if I had to choose, I'd go with the one on the right, simply because it looks more natural.[/color]